A commercial business in Canada is allowed to collect personal information without the knowledge or consent of the individual in all of the following circumstances EXCEPT when?
- AThe collection is for journalistic or literary purposes.Falls under the statutory exception in PIPEDA s. 7(1)(c) for journalistic, artistic or literary purposes, allowing the organization to collect without consent.
- BThe collection is in the interests of the individual and the consent cannot be obtained in a timely way.Falls under the statutory exception in PIPEDA s. 7(1)(a) where collection is clearly in the interests of the individual and timely consent cannot be obtained.
- CThe collection would lead to the creation of products that would benefit the public and consent would be difficult to obtain.
- DThe collection, with the knowledge of the individual, would compromise the availability and accuracy of the information and the collection is reasonable for the purposes related to investigating a federal law.Falls under the statutory exception in PIPEDA s. 7(1)(b) for investigating a breach of federal law, where obtaining consent with the individual's knowledge would compromise the integrity of the information.
PIPEDA s. 7(1) lists a limited set of exceptions under which a commercial organization may collect personal information without the knowledge or consent of the individual, including: collection for journalistic, artistic or literary purposes (corresponding to option A); collection that is clearly in the interests of the individual and consent cannot be obtained in a timely way (corresponding to option B); and collection where obtaining consent with the individual's knowledge would compromise the availability or accuracy of the information, and the collection is reasonable for purposes related to investigating a breach of federal law (corresponding to option D). These exceptions are all explicitly enumerated in the statute and therefore are not what "EXCEPT" refers to. By contrast, "collection would lead to the creation of products that benefit the public and consent would be difficult to obtain" is not an exception provided under PIPEDA s. 7(1). Simply invoking "the product benefits the public" or "consent is hard to obtain" as grounds for waiving the consent requirement has no legal basis and does not appear among the ten fair information principles in Schedule 1 of PIPEDA or the specific list of exceptions in s. 7. Option C is therefore the situation in which collecting personal information without consent is not permitted.